What is a diagnosis?

It's just a label1, agreed upon by by the particular community. A diagnosis should conjure up the same clinical story and picture for any practitioner worldwide, allowing "apples to be compared with apples" (and not with oranges.)

It may be a fairly artificial abstraction, to isolate a manageable portion of a larger continuum. Chronic fatigue syndrome is a small group in the large population of people with chronic tiredness, who had a fairly sudden onset of the condition.

Sometimes a diagnosis is established by just one pathognomonic feature in the clinical picture. Koplik's spots inside the cheeks mean one thing only. This child has measles, even if the characteristic rash is yet to appear.

Sailors of yesteryear had to show their palms during inspection, as smallpox caused a rash there.

Diagnostic tests are  used extensively, but are frequently misleading, putting up red herrings to draw one off the scent."Transaminitis" is a tongue in cheek term for an unexplained transaminase liver test elevation. Lumbar spine X-rays often show arthritis which has little to do with a person's backache.

"Screening tests" are valuable first steps in looking for cancer of the cervix or large bowel, but  in the case of breast and prostate are of little value compared to the trouble they cause.

A selected panel of screening tests can avoid things being forgotten and may save physicians' time (and so money.) The results then have to be considered in the clinical context, to make sense of them and prevent one wasting effort on false leads.

Diagnosis equals understanding?

Not on your Nellie! to quote Dr. J. Brody2
"One of the main reasons why the treatment of enuresis brings so many bitter disappointments to patient and physician alike is the almost universal attitude of considering enuresis as a disease. Too many failures are due to this mistaken attempt to force the condition into the straitjacket of a clinical entity (single diagnostic category) and to find the single treatment which will cure all cases of enuresis - be it drug, psychotherapy or electric (read "magic") machine. Once it is recognized that enuresis is but a symptom - the underlying cause of which can be any of a widely differing variety of conditions, ranging from anatomical anomaly, through infection, metabolic disturbance, psychological disturbance, to habit - and once the cause has been identified, the first big step towards eventual cure has been taken."
Lots of other "diagnoses" such as asthma, are really just descriptions of a prominent symptom (here variable airways obstruction.) Psychiatry is full of such superficial labelling.

The context

Even if a very distinct clinical entity is diagnosed, that is only part of the story. The premorbid state of health and psychosocial functioning will have a large effect on the prognosis, even to the extent "make or break." One person with cancer will quickly throw in the towel and another will fight to the bitter end. A terminal disease diagnosis may help a person to completely turn their life around, and some people in this situation have expressed thankfulness for this opportunity.

I heard Elizabeth Kubler-Ross speak years ago, in Melbourne. She said she saw value for people to have an extended terminal illness, as it gave them more time to set things right with their circle of family and acquaintances.

How and why

Quoting from Dr. William Orchard, a psychiatrist from the Melbourne Royal Children's Hospital in the 1960s...
"The widespread tendency among doctors is still to tend to view disease as an alien which has invaded an otherwise healthy human being. The aim of many physicians, often unstated and unrecognized as such, is to discern this alien, attach a label to it, for example appendicitis, lobar pneumonia, etc. and then to attack this alien through an effective technique, for example surgery or an antibiotic - the "concept of the magic bullet."
The emphasis is predominantly on how a patient is sick, attach a label and treat the label. The approach tends to dehumanize the patient and focus on this alien....
Increasingly today doctors are asking not only how a patient is sick, but why, and particularly why at this particular time in life."

It's worth asking yourself and asking your practitioner: why? And possibly asking the same question following the first answer: again, why? Just keep digging, to your "bottom line." This is "root cause medicine." Things like birth by caesarean section (without inoculation with your mother's intestinal microbiome) and multiple early childhood adverse experiences, are foundations of much adult illness.

Dr Denis Burkitt was on the same tack many years ago3. He obviously enjoyed trying to kid his audiences into thinking about causes.
"Researchers have consistently overlooked the connection between a low-fiber diet, poor bovel habits, and abdominal gas and reflux. Thirty-five years ago, Dr. Denis Burkitt concluded that based an his own research, GE reflux, hiatal hemias, low-fiher diets, delayed intestinal transit of leftovers, and suboptimal bowel habits were intrinsically related. The missing link for Dr. Burkilt was the development of a fiber program that allows people to adapt a high-fiber diet as painlessly as possible.
So convinced was Dr. Burkitt that physicians were headed in the wrong direction that one of his favorite cartoons that he presented at medical conferences was that of two physicians busily mopping the floor from an overflowing sink, but they never bother to turn off the faucet or work on the blocked drain! He comparcd this behavior of physicians to doing surgery for reflux or prescribing medications. Fixing the blocked drain (constipation and gas) would do more to help people than all the medicines and surgeries (mopping up the floor) combined."

DIY looking for causes of symptoms

If you are interested in a home study course on examination of the spine, please send me your e-mail address by the contact form.

notes and references

1. To quote Grant Taylor from www.taylorhealthdesign.com
"Disease is a concept that throughout history has been a product of efforts to explain and remedy ill-health. It is inextricably tied to prevailing concepts about the causes of ill-health and our ability to describe them – whether by invoking demons, curses, miasma, microbes, disturbances to energy flows or environmental toxins. Ill-health is a fact (or at least a phenomenon) but a disease is nothing more than an idea – the continually evolving nature of which is evidenced by the revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) ten times in little more than 100 years."

2. A New Look at Enuresis J Brody LRCP LRCS DCH Medical Journal of Australia April 20 1963 pp 578-580

3. Cure Constipation Now: A Doctor's Fiber Therapy to Cleanse and Heal By Wes Jones

Click to return to the main index page from this page on diagnosis.


Is there something else you would like to read about?
This search button will bring up anywhere on this site your words are mentioned...


Custom Search


The contactpage.

If you are interested in a home study course on examination of the spine, please send me your e-mail address by the contact form.